bali, what how why bali ritual

If so why to kill other pranies why not man kill himself?

and why to kill at all

he can prostrate to indicate surrender

by killing pranies, one is going away from god who is living in the pranies

i have a different story

''collapsing of wholeness''

creation happens by collapsing the existing wholeness and 

reuniting into new wholeness

like a bark on the tree, green strong integral, 

collapses cracks breaks, 

to give way to new bark from within fresh strong green healthy 

A seed breaks, collapses in sprouting afresh

here there is no destruction

it is renewal of life

a renovation a rejuvenation old gong, giving pace to new

saying---''old order changeth yielding place to new

This a sacrifice, in a sense, I recall ''anna ''----referring this sprout phenomena calling for a few men to sacrifice themselves in the cause of bringing new order in the nation 

In the process of coconut breaking, 

this collapsing phenomena is symbolic ,

at the same time good auger to bring in the subtle effect of creativity getting enlivened in the vicinity in the consciousness of individuals and probably in the entire universe.

so this is considered auspicious

why coconut 

probably it gives some dramatic effect with its obstinacy of hard shell, yet yielding to fulfill the god ordained purpose .

and it will not disturb the sentiment of ahimsa in some, 

as it is harmless, as compared to animal /human /child /bird sacrifices

an egg breaking also the ''breaking before making'' in becoming bird 

Egg is just an example of wholeness collapsing, 

i did not mean it a pooja material .leave it there

but see the total perspective, of how universe is evolving 

by moment to moment/

or periodical collapse of wholeness

dharma getting violated, and getting restored 

some thing sprouting, growing, dying, 

and some new thing of the same getting born 

It is the collapse of the whole ness ‘’ a ‘’

in the ‘’ akshara ‘’

ie,  kshara of ‘’ a ‘’

collapse of wholeness, 

and then, 

navo navo bhavathi ,

unmanifest fullness collapses itself and becomes the manifest, 

manifest takes birth . –

-any ritual has the basis , which can be known only by one who has the experience of absolute, 

if not it becomes meaningless, 

becomes subject of wrong interpretations and harm, 

though in reality the rituals are profound, founded on the basis of absolute reality seen by rishis 

it's the shiva aspect , laya, the destruction –

----out of the three , …..create, sustain ,destroy--..is to be understood -- a contra enigma, creation and destruction go hand in hand 

the basic concept is  '' wholeness collapsing'' and 

generation degeneration to regeneration 

nothing new

yet

 every thing new

rose is same

but every rose is new

we offer a fullness to god

by collapsing that fullness, coconut

to enabling the creator to reconstruct a new fullness

great is our rishi sanskruthi, 

seeing nothing as unimportant , 

nothing out of place, even contra , 

appearing bad/useless/negative/ugly/meaningless

it's the seeing ability, in the seeing technology that bharath excels, and expands to embrace the universe